Expert Picks: 2016’s Best Eye Creams

Aren’t dark circles fun? And crows feet? Even worse than having any kind of problem area under your eye is getting ripped off… Buying a cream only to find out you wasted your money and it does nothing is an extremely frustrating experience. And an unfortunately common one, for that matter.

That’s why I’ve rounded up the list of the best eye creams so that you don’t end up disappointed.

Disclaimer: Every eye cream works differently for everyone. At the end of the day, something that works for me might not work well for you. Something that works well for you might not work well for me. But in an effort to help guide your search for the best eye creams, I have gathered what I feel are the best across a wide variety of prices that should all help you.

Another thing I have to say: while these products do work and do help do things such as decrease puffiness, have an anti-aging effect and such… one thing that I am always sort of skeptical about is totally diminishing dark circles. While they can help and definitely create some results, by no means will any cream be a magical cure.

With that said, let’s begin.

#10: Osmosis Refresh Eye Serum, $60

This is an insanely, well, “refreshing” eye serum. I have tried others that are effective but aren’t lightweight enough to be able to wear… especially in the day! This one is surprisingly very potent but not greasy. You will want to buy it if you want something that you can wear while still looking shine free. Also good for dry skin and oily skin… in other words, anyone and everyone can use this!

Osmosis Refresh Eye Serum, $60

#9: Natura Bisse Diamond Extreme Eye Cream, $205

This is supposed to help any aging as well as hydrate the delicate, fragile skin under your eye. The “secret” behind it is that it is supposed to “trigger your skin’s own defense mechanisms in order to repair your skin and protect it from harmful aggressors. Extremely rich, it gives you energy, regenerates, fights wrinkles, provides elasticity, firmness and maintains an optimal state of hydration.”

Now, I would not say this is 100% accurate, but some of it is true. It is definitely an extremely rich cream and is a heavy duty one as well.
What ingredients does it contain that are supposed to produce these dazzling effects?


“Artemia Salina extract creates the energy necessary to stimulate cellular metabolism.” In addition, “Centellaasiatica, calendula, horse chestnut, horsetail and licorice are responsible for the decongestive, draining effect that minimizes under-eye circles and puffiness.”

I know it is very expensive, so if you 1) cannot afford it and 2) don’t really need a heavy-duty eye cream, I don’t advise purchasing this one. If, on the other hand, you definitely can afford it and are looking for a very heavy duty eye cream and have tried all sorts of other brands that have not worked for you, you might as well give this one a try to see if you see good results. :)

Natura Bisse Diamond Extreme Eye Cream, $205

#8 Clinique All About Eyes Cream, $32

This is a classic eye cream that I’ve liked for years, which is why I have to include it on this list. I have a special fondness for these kind of creams, because I love things that are lightweight and are going to not screw up my makeup. This cream/gel consistency is ideal when it comes to makeup application. It will not create any kind of greasy, frustrating effect. It is a very good one for people who have combination to oily skin. In addition, it is known to help decrease puffiness around the eyes and even somewhat help undereye circles (somewhat).

The bottom line about this one is, it is “An award-winning, lightweight eye cream-gel that diminishes the appearance of eye puffiness, darkness, and fine lines.” There is a reason it’s award winning. And the price is relatively reasonable. It’s a good buy.

Clinique All About Eyes Cream, $32

#7 Nuance Salma Hayek Intense Hydration Restoring Eye Cream, $19.99

This eye cream contains Royal jelly, honey, blue agave and fruit extracts. It is going to hydrate and condition the delicate skin under your eye. It is also designed to help with aging. The reason Royal Jelly is a secret weapon in this cream is because it “is a bee product created from a combination of honey and pollen. Ancient Egyptians were master beekeepers who used royal jelly for its protein-rich, skin-softening benefits.”

Honestly, though, if you have really bad problems with dark circles and fun eye issues like that, I would opt for another, more intensive, cream. If you generally want a solid cream for under your eyes, though, this one works well.

Nuance Salma Hayek Intense Hydration Restoring Eye Cream, $19.99

#6: CeraVe Eye Repair Cream, $13.99

It promises to reduce the appearance of dark circles, diminish any puffiness and help to “repair and restore the protective skin barrier.” It contains ceramides and hyaluronic acid, both ingredients that you want to find in an eye cream. This is a very lightweight cream that’s also affordable, so it can’t hurt to try it. There is no real reason not to. It has solid ingredients that are going to 1) be effective and 2) not irritate your skin!

CeraVe Eye Repair Cream, $13.99

#5: Peter Thomas Roth Mega Rich Intensive Anti-Aging Cellular Eye Cream, $65

This is an excellent, reliable brand when it comes to all-things skin care, which includes eye cream!

The type of cream this is… is for those who need an intense eye cream designed to hydrate and combat pesky wrinkles formulating around your eye area.

What ingredients does this contain and why is it a solid eye cream?


It contains “Firma-cell-4™ and added anti-aging benefits helps reduce the visual severity of deep wrinkles and fine lines for younger looking skin. This formula supports natural collagen production and elastin synthesis and goes beyond retinol to firm, smooth, and visibly lift the delicate eye area.

In addition, the combined antiaging benefits of Firma-cell-4™, ceramide 3, vitamins A, ascorbic C, E, and pro-vitamin B5 make this a truly revolutionary treatment.”

I do not know if I would use the word “revolutionary,” but… it certainly is effective and a good choice if you really want something anti-aging and heavy duty enough to help wrinkles (not make them disappear, because only Botox can do this, but help). :)

If you are trying to diminish dark circles, this one might not be for you. But if your goal is anti-aging, then it’s awesome.

Peter Thomas Roth Mega Rich Intensive Anti-Aging Cellular Eye Cream, $65

#4: Olay Fresh Effects Eye Awakening Cream, $12.99 – $14.99

This one is a must have because of its affordable price point and effectiveness. Olay has notoriously good anti-aging products, which also applies to the eye cream! This is going to help diminish crow’s feet and plump up the fragile skin around your eye area. And when you consider the price… How can you not get it?

Olay Fresh Effects Eye Awakening Cream, $12.99 – $14.99

#3: Tarte Maracuja C-Brighter Eye Treatment, $38

Tarte is normally known for its makeup, but has a surprisingly good eye cream as well. Very, very good, in fact. I love this brand in general… and its eye cream is no exception. What does this contain?


It is, “An intense, maracuja fruit- and vitamin C-infused, multitasking eye-treatment that visibly hydrates, firms, and brightens the delicate eye-area.”

Its purpose is to “refresh, renew, and recharge tired eyes. This skintuitive™ eye treatment contains rice bran, mango, and coconut, which are naturally rich in antioxidants and help fight signs of aging and free radical damage. Meanwhile, oat sugars instantly smooth and visibly tighten skin. The nutrient-rich formula also delivers the ultimate in hydration for smooth, youthful-looking eyes.”

I love how this works to brighten the under eye area, making it a solid choice if you have dark circles under your eyes as well. The brightening factor comes from maracuja oil. “Maracuja” oil is rich in essential fatty acids that are known to replenish, rebuild, and brighten skin. Along with a high dose of pure vitamin C that gives the appearance of brighter skin, a powerful antiaging elixir promotes active skin recovery, rejuvenation, and maximum hydration that quenches dry skin.”

And, of course, there are none of the bad three: Parabens, Sulfates or Phthalates (which are irritants to your delicate skin). It is also safe for your under eye area (and has been tested by ophthalmologists.)

This cream is going to help you if you use it over time. I love it.

Tarte Maracuja C-Brighter Eye Treatment, $38

#2: La Prairie Cellular Revitalizing Eye Gel, $180

If you happen to have extra cash and are willing to spend the money, this one is excellent. It comes in a pretty jar and feels excellent when applied. It has an almost cooling sensation that’s hard to describe.

It isn’t a super rich or intense cream, but will offer some hydration. It’s also a delightful de-puffer and will fight against dark circles. Will use over time, dark circles will slowly improve.

In addition, this “helps to eliminate the inflammation, dehydration and loss of youthful firmness in the eye area. This ultimate eye-care treatment was designed with multi-action interceptors that counterattack at every stage of aging helping to prevent, repair and maintain the delicate skin around the eye area.

And it’s packaging is extremely pretty. It’s an adorable light blue that I love to look at. I know this isn’t relevant, but it’s true. It looks delicious on your makeup counter, vanity or bathroom sink. Love love love.

La Prairie Cellular Revitalizing Eye Gel, $180

#1: Drunk Elephant Shaba Complex Eye Serum, $85

This one is extremely effective at soothing your under eye area. If used over time, it’s going to gradually decrease dark circles and make your eye area less puffy. It’s also excellent for sensitive skin, is fragrance free and contains excellent soothing properties. The packaging is unique, too. It doesn’t come in a jar but rather an almost dispensary pump type of thing. It’s easy to preserve the quality of the cream and to dispense just the right amount for your under eye area.

It contains no parabens or sulfates, either. Its strong concentration of black tea ferment as well as copper peptides are going to act as anti-aging ingredients. In addition, “a derivative of the flavonoid hesperdin works to reduce dark circles while powerful antioxidants in Co-Q10 fade age spots.”

The reason this eye cream stands out is because it isn’t just going to help you temporarily or on the surface, it’s actually designed to deliver real results, not just temporary camoflauge.

I love this one. I have actually been using it any time I want to soothe my under-eye area. It’s an amazing one, truly. I highly recommend it.

Drunk Elephant Shaba Complex Eye Serum, $85

Bonus Tip: Use Cucumber

In addition to consistently using an eye cream, you can always use a sliced up cucumber for a quick de-puff!

In summary…

These Are The Best Eye Creams

  1. Drunk Elephant shaba complex eye serum
  2. La Prairie cellular revitalizing eye gel
  3. Tarte maracuja c-brighter eye treatment
  4. Olay fresh effects eye awakening cream
  5. Peter Thomas Roth mega rich intensive anti-aging cellular eye cream
  6. CeraVe eye repair cream
  7. Nuance Salma Hayek intense hydration restoring eye cream
  8. Clinique all about eyes cream
  9. Natura Bisse diamond extreme eye cream

best eye creams

31 comments… add one
  • laura con January 16, 2017, 7:04 pm

    I agree with Vogue UK, that the Made from Earth Chamomile Eye Therapy is #1. Vogue in the US has put them as #4, but that Chamomile Eye Therapy deserves to be #1 cause I saw the best results using that – and this is coming from someone who used to have very tired looking eyes.

  • wilma August 19, 2016, 12:45 pm

    super love La Prairie products! though a bit more pricey than others, important thing is it really works!

  • lucy August 18, 2016, 4:13 pm

    nice list of products!

  • lyn August 17, 2016, 2:39 pm

    I love how Tarte Maracuja works to brighten the under eye area, this is a great product!

  • dina August 16, 2016, 12:53 pm

    nice to see an article like this, it gave me more options about beauty creams!

  • monique August 15, 2016, 12:56 pm

    olay is effective and affordable! you must try this! :)

  • kaela August 12, 2016, 12:37 pm

    needed something like this article, i’ll try some of these products. thanks!

  • marcene August 11, 2016, 12:41 pm

    will definitely try out some items on this list, thanks!

  • rosie August 10, 2016, 12:59 pm

    thanks for this article, i’ve been looking for something to refresh my stressed eyes after a hard day’s work… i’ll definitely try Tarte!

  • khady August 9, 2016, 1:30 pm

    love this article! i will definitely share this to my friends! :)

  • joslyn August 9, 2016, 1:09 am

    i love CeraVe products..i use their facial wash and moisturizer so i think i’m going to try their eye cream. :)

  • tammy August 5, 2016, 11:56 pm

    so happy about this post..can’t wait to try some of the products you listed

  • kamila August 4, 2016, 11:21 pm

    just what i need right now..ive been so stressed and had less sleep..need to take care of my eyes

  • jean August 3, 2016, 7:17 pm

    upon reading, i know these are all great products. i’m not familiar with the others but they seem to deliver great results and i can’t wait to try them out

  • darla August 2, 2016, 6:54 pm

    La Prairie may seem pricey but you’ll use for the longest time and the benefits are real! (:

  • carol August 1, 2016, 9:13 pm

    more skin care product posts please??! love it! <3

  • gwyneth July 29, 2016, 9:24 pm

    Clinique’s eye cream has done wonders for me..i love their beauty products from skin are to make up

  • harmony July 28, 2016, 6:25 pm

    i love Natura Bisse products and so im thinking of getting this eye cream..i really need to try it

  • everly July 27, 2016, 12:25 pm

    i think im gonna try La Prairie’s..i like its packaging and the description of its benefits. i have dark under eyes and wanna get rid of them..hope it works

  • elisa July 26, 2016, 12:18 pm

    i love everything about beauty esp facial care tips!

  • gene July 25, 2016, 11:55 pm

    tarte is the best pick for me! :)

  • doris July 22, 2016, 3:47 pm

    olay really works for me even their moisturizer, my skin loves it! also, no need to splurge

  • gay July 21, 2016, 12:58 pm

    i definitely wanna try the Drunk Elephant eye serum. it sounds so promising! :))

  • ivette July 20, 2016, 2:55 pm

    i love skin care products, im definitely going to check out these products.

  • debra July 19, 2016, 1:12 pm

    i would love to really try La Prairie products..they’re just costly compare to other stuff

  • fairy July 18, 2016, 12:34 pm

    love beauty articles, this one’s a big help for my always tired eyes.

  • izzy July 14, 2016, 2:08 pm

    wow..i want to try the drunk elephant stuff, hope it works for me too :)

  • deria July 13, 2016, 2:19 pm

    i have always loved olay products which i took after my grandmother..i’d like to get the eye doubt it will be worth the try.

  • irina July 12, 2016, 7:28 pm

    haven’t tried Peter Thomas Roth yet, but ive heard some great things about the eye cream..ill make a little bit more of a research

  • colleen July 11, 2016, 7:58 pm

    wow, i love this post! will research more about this products and try them.

  • chandra July 7, 2016, 11:12 pm

    ive tried CeraVe..its effective and inexpensive..its a winner for me! (:

Leave a Comment